Giddyup! It's a record review roundup!
I've heard a couple albums recently and wish to voice my opinions on them. Am I talking to the right person? If not, could you please transfer me? Yes, I'll hold.
The Sea and Cake's Everybody pretty much sounds like all the other Sea and Cake albums, but it's really great and gets better with every listen.
The Innocence Mission's We Walked In Song pretty much sounds like all the other Innocence Mission albums, but it's kind of forgettable.
Fountains of Wayne's Traffic and Weather pretty much sounds like all the other Fountains of Wayne albums, but it's actually kind of bad.
Tracy Thorn's Out of the Woods sounds like a work of obligation from an artist for whom the thrill is long gone.
Brett Anderson's eponymous album sounds like a work of obligation from an artist for whom the thrill is long gone.
Maxïmo Park's Our Earthly Pleasure shows that what made their first album great was not the sound but the songs. And these songs just aren't as good.
Amy Winehouse's Back to Black is beautifully produced and arranged, but ultimately ruined by that oft-unacknowledged irony: that imitating the style and accent of a soul singer is faking a kind of music that takes its very name from sincerity.
Lavender Diamond threw out all the good stuff from their first EP and kept all the cheesy stuff that might remind some cynics of, like, Enya.
Clap Your Hands, Say Yeah's Some Loud Thunder has some great songs that are marred by the singer's wildly successful attempts to annoy everybody.
Speaking of albums that are Marr-ed, the new Modest Mouse record is pretty good, but mostly worthwhile for those moments when you think, "There could be no one playing that guitar part but Johnny Marr." And all is right with the world.
I think that Bloc Party somehow heard me when I thought, "Could this album be more boring?" and took it as a challenge.
Ozomatli's Don't Mess With the Dragon is, sadly, pretty bad.
Dntel's Dumb Luck is, in a word, blippy. All those guest vocalists are gonna get you all excited, but they must have all left the studio with their heads hung low, thinking the same thing: "Aw, damn. Jimmy's setting all his good stuff aside for the next Postal Service record."
Andrew Bird's Armchair Apocrypha is good, but not nearly as good as the first few listens led me to believe.
Sarah Shannon's City Morning Song is good, but not nearly as good as the first few listens led me to believe.
Thanks for stopping by, and on your way out, please pause by the giveaway bin and check out some songs that our staff recommends by Sondre Lerche, the Apples In Stereo, Panda Bear and The Klaxons.
15 comments:
That was fun; you reviewed some things I didn't even know existed yet. Will you be my NME, Reid? For the record, I have very modest hopes for the Maximo Park. For some reason, I'm getting a one album wonder vibe from them. Fountains of Wayne...I'm having a hard time even caring any more. The last one had nice moments, but they're not nearly as clever as they think they are. For some reason I fear a let down from Wilco is on the way too. Ho hum. My hopes, however, are sky high for the new Arcade Fire. I wish it would appear in my mailbox already.
Maybe I just need a little more time with the Maximo Park record, but even the songs that have really exciting moments let me down in the end.
Fountains of Wayne is one of those bands where you always know what you're getting, and I do think that they're pretty damn clever, but this new one...you just want to pat them on the back and say, "Sorry, guys. Just didn't happen this time. We'll get 'em next time." Plus, the album has a ridiculous song called "Planet of Weed" that's one of the dumbest odes to pot ever, and that's saying a lot. "Ha! People who are high get the munchies! It's so true!"
You can listen to the Arcade Fire over here at 3voor12.
I'm not going to rewrite the post, but I thought after I published it that my review of the Ozomatli record should actually have been:
"Ozomatli's Don't Mess With The Dragon? More like, Don't Step in the Dragon's Mess. That's bad, but so is the album."
Anyway, Field Music, LCD Soundsystem and Of Montreal are still ruling my 2007. But I need some new sounds. Anyone?
Can we talk about the Arcade Fire? I'm not buying it. Sounds vaguely gothy or proggy or something. I can't decide if this is one of those things that needs room to breathe and grow on you -something not easily done listening to 30 second clips on iTunes.
I heard the new Fountains of Wayne single the other day, and thoughtt "oh that's catchy. They've been around for ages, and why didn't I ever get into them?" Then I remember that back in the mid 90s they weren't all that good (Ivy being a much better project), and then I remember "Stacy's Mom" and feel a little sour grapes - that's a way better version of "Mom's New Boyfriend." ;)
I'm with Xtian, more 1-2 sentence music reviews. This ruled.
Jen, if you're not already listening to the Arcade Fire, the hype is going to be nearly impossible to overcome.
There's nothing really proggy, but there's a little bit of goth in there. In spite of what Paul might say, there's some Echo (and you too, Bunnymen) in there. Listen to "The Cutter" and then "Intervention" and tell me there's not at least a family resemblance.
Here's my one-line review: Arcade Fire's Neon Bible is brilliant, but still, I've found myself listening to Funeral more often.
FOW always make me smile, even when they're bad. This album just isn't very good. It's an extremely fine line with a band like FOW.
I'm glad y'all like the one-line reviews, but you know that I'm never going to give up the long, ramling reviews. It's just the way I am.
Yeah! That was fun! More please.
I haven't bought much new stuff, but I'm really loving the new Shins and Peter Bjorn & John. Seeing the Shins on Friday - pretty excited about that. I like it.
And, if that song "Someone Great" is any indication of what it's like, I need to finally get the entire LCD Soundsystem...because I love that freaking song.
Amy Winehouse bought herself a permanent place in my cold, cold heart with "Tears Dry On Their Own." I would crawl over glass for that song. Your point on imitation is well taken, but the sheer joy I get from that sweet soul music pushes those thoughts way back in my head. I am looking forward to cleaning, dancing, and lip syncing in the mirror with hairbrush in hand to her record for many months to come.
Wait a second... you have every new record know and unknown to man, and you're asking *us* for recommendations??!
Hmmm...well, I can't vouch for it, but I bet you have access to the new Charlotte Hatherley. The two new songs I heard on her myspace sounded great. I loved the first one and look forward to hearing what she's done to follow it.
I'm listening to the new Air at that Dutch site (I'm not going to stream the Arcade Fire...I prefer to wait however long) and it sounds....boring.
Now I'm streaming the Gruff Rhys solo album at Dutchy.com...and it sounds excellent. If you like Super Furry Animals...
Doug, you know you make the rest of us bitter with jealousy that you get to see those shows at the Ryman, right?
Susan, I know...I shouldn't hold it against her. The songs are great. And hell, if I can forgive Bruce Springsteen for his Cletus voice on Nebraska, I suppose I can be a little more forgiving of Ms. Not Exactly The First White British Woman To Pretend She's A Black American/Jamaican. I'll definitely be listening to it again.
Christian, I'm just looking for some different stuff. My list may be kind of long, but it's not exactly diverse. It drives me crazy that there's tons of amazing stuff out there that I'm not hearing because my music tastes are more, uh, focused than I'd like for them to be.
Yeah, true, the Ryman - it's a pretty great place. Come on down for a show!
BTW, your sidebar google reader thingy has had some really good stuff in there lately. I love that map site, and now I know how much beer I need to buy for my lavish parties.
Xtian, you hang out on my space?
Define "hang out", Jen! I use myspace pretty much exclusively as place to hear new bands. I don't have an account or friends or anything like that...not that there's anything wrong with that, of course. It's just the easiest way to answer the question "hey I wonder what that band sounds like?" seeing as how every band and then some has a myspace page. Knowhutimean?
Air: I've tried listening to the new album.
The Arcade Fire: I keep listening to the new album.
LCD Soundsystem: I haven't listened to the new album, at least not as a whole, but every time the iTunes gods throw me one of its tracks, my ears perk up and I have to check to see what's playing.
Xtian hangs out in "my space", if you know what I mean.
Post a Comment